3 best practices to adopt into your board fundraising
Mastering the Art of a Board Fundraising Campaign: Engaging Strategies, Policies, and Pitfalls
A Board Fundraising Campaign has the potential to elevate nonprofit fundraising and deepen board members’ involvement in the organization’s mission. Board members, as leaders and ambassadors, bring crucial influence to their organizations, making their active participation in fundraising essential. To build an effective board fundraising campaign, it’s critical to establish a strategic plan that encourages their involvement and clarifies expectations. By setting clear guidelines and cultivating a culture of philanthropy on the board, nonprofits can unlock both financial support and meaningful engagement.
Why a Board Fundraising Campaign Is Crucial
A well-designed Board Fundraising Campaign aligns board members with the organization’s funding goals and serves as a testament to the board’s commitment to the mission. Active involvement in fundraising helps board members feel more invested in the nonprofit’s vision and strengthens their sense of purpose within the organization. Additionally, board participation in fundraising efforts enhances credibility by signaling to other donors that the leadership is financially committed to the cause.
“When board members actively fundraise, it underscores their belief in the mission and demonstrates shared accountability for its success,” says one seasoned nonprofit consultant. “Their involvement speaks volumes to the community about the importance of this work.”
Strategies to Engage the Board in Fundraising
Effectively engaging the board in a fundraising campaign takes thoughtful planning and strategic involvement. Here are several practical approaches to foster board participation in fundraising:
- Set Expectations During Recruitment
Establish fundraising as a board responsibility from the start. Potential members should understand that participation in fundraising is part of their commitment, which ensures clarity and readiness among those joining the board. - Provide Training and Resources
Since not all board members may be experienced fundraisers, regular training and resources—like workshops on donor engagement and relationship building—help equip them with the tools they need. Providing a fundraising mentor within the organization or connecting them with staff liaisons can also boost confidence. - Involve Board Members in Donor Cultivation and Events
Inviting board members to donor gatherings, gala events, and cultivation meetings gives them an active role in connecting with prospective supporters. When board members engage with donors personally, they can foster relationships that benefit both the board member and the organization. - Celebrate Contributions and Successes
Acknowledging board members’ achievements fosters a culture of appreciation. Publicly celebrating their fundraising contributions, regardless of size, can motivate others to take part and enhance morale across the board. - Offer Multiple Ways to Engage
Board members bring a variety of strengths, so allowing flexibility in how they contribute to fundraising can encourage wider participation. For instance, some may host events or make introductions, while others can lend their expertise in marketing or donor communications.
Board Giving Policies: Yes or No?
Board giving policies are often a focal point in Board Fundraising Campaigns, as they establish expectations for financial contributions or fundraising from each member. While many nonprofits find these policies beneficial, the decision to implement one requires careful consideration of organizational culture and board capacity. These policies generally fall into three types: give, get, and give-or-get policies.
Breaking Down Give, Get, and Give-or-Get Policies
Understanding the strengths and potential drawbacks of each policy type is crucial to choosing the right approach:
- Give Policy: This type of policy requires board members to make a personal donation, often with a suggested minimum amount.
- Pros: Personal contributions signal a high level of commitment and credibility. When board members financially invest in the organization, it affirms their belief in the cause.
- Cons: This approach can be limiting for board members with financial constraints. If the minimum amount is beyond reach for some members, it may discourage otherwise valuable individuals from serving on the board.
- Get Policy: In a “get” policy, board members are expected to fundraise a certain amount through external sources. This could involve soliciting donations, organizing events, or leveraging their networks to contribute.
- Pros: This approach allows board members to contribute by harnessing their connections, expanding the nonprofit’s reach. It’s especially helpful for board members who may have robust networks but limited personal giving capacity.
- Cons: “Get” policies can be difficult for board members without extensive networks, potentially putting pressure on them to fulfill the financial expectations. It also may lead to inconsistent contributions if some members are more comfortable with fundraising than others.
- Give-or-Get Policy: This flexible policy allows board members to either make a personal donation or meet a fundraising target by securing contributions from others.
- Pros: Flexibility accommodates members’ differing financial situations and professional connections. It also empowers each board member to contribute in a way that feels meaningful to them.
- Cons: A “give-or-get” policy may lack uniformity in contributions and could lead to misunderstandings if some members feel they are contributing more than others.
Best Practices for Implementing a Board Giving Policy
For organizations considering a board giving policy, there are several best practices to keep in mind:
- Match Policy with Organizational Values: Choose a policy that reflects your organization’s mission and culture. A small community nonprofit might adopt a different policy approach than a large national organization, depending on board members’ backgrounds and available resources.
- Be Transparent About Expectations: Communicate the policy clearly and openly, especially during recruitment. Having transparent conversations about expectations helps avoid misunderstandings and ensures candidates are aligned with the organization’s needs.
- Assess and Adjust the Policy Over Time: Periodically review the policy to ensure it meets the organization’s needs and consider any necessary adjustments. Board composition, fundraising goals, or organizational priorities may evolve, so having a flexible approach can keep the policy relevant.
“The most effective policies provide structure without rigidity,” shares an industry expert. “Policies should support, not stifle, the board’s enthusiasm and creativity in fundraising.”
Pitfalls to Avoid in a Board Fundraising Campaign
Launching a board fundraising campaign can be rewarding, but several common pitfalls can hinder its effectiveness. Here are a few to watch out for:
- Unattainable Financial Goals
Setting overly ambitious goals can discourage participation if members feel the expectations are unrealistic. Consider the financial abilities and fundraising skills of the entire board when setting targets. - Insufficient Training and Resources
Without proper training and support, board members may feel overwhelmed or unsure of how to engage in fundraising. Offering regular workshops or connecting them with mentors can help build their skills and confidence. - Transactional Relationships
A campaign that feels solely financially driven can lead to transactional relationships. Emphasizing relationship-building helps create a deeper, more meaningful connection between board members and the organization. - Overlooking Recognition
Celebrating each board member’s contribution fosters a culture of appreciation and motivation. Small gestures of recognition—whether in meetings, newsletters, or events—can make a significant difference in sustaining engagement. - Leadership Setting the Wrong Tone
If the board fundraising campaign isn’t championed enthusiastically by leadership, it may come across as an obligation rather than an opportunity. Board members should see leaders actively supporting the campaign, setting a positive example.
Building a Sustainable Board Fundraising Campaign
Ultimately, a successful Board Fundraising Campaign extends beyond financial gains. It’s an opportunity to foster a deeper connection among board members, strengthen their commitment to the mission, and develop a culture of giving and involvement. By thoughtfully engaging board members, selecting an appropriate giving policy, and avoiding common pitfalls, nonprofits can create a sustainable approach to board fundraising. This type of campaign not only bolsters revenue but also enriches the organization’s culture, inspiring board members to become passionate advocates.
For nonprofits looking to strengthen their board fundraising initiatives, NonprofitFreelancers.com is an essential resource. The platform connects nonprofits with skilled freelance consultants who specialize in board engagement, fundraising strategy, and campaign management. By working with experienced professionals, organizations can gain the insights and support needed to implement a successful board fundraising campaign, fostering an environment where both the board and the organization can thrive.
External Resources:
